Online Journalism News

Do not forget about 'off-the-street' whistleblowers, says Phillip Knightley

Posted: 26/11/08 By: Oliver Shah

Email this story | Comments

Journalists working in a digital age should not underestimate the importance of 'off-the-street' whistleblowing, investigative journalist and author Phillip Knightley has said.

The transformation of newspapers into commercial machines is strangling investigative journalism and leaving huge scoops uncovered, Knightley said at a City University event on November 25, 'Adventures in Journalism: Tall Tales and True Scoops'.

Knightley, the award-winning reporter who led the Sunday Times' legendary Insight team between 1965 and 1985, said it was a 'great mistake' for newspapers to move from city centre premises to cheaper out-of-town locations, making access more difficult for potential sources.

The migration had severed one of the fundamental links between investigative journalists and their informants, Knightley argued.

"A newspaper has got to be in the centre of things," he said. "Prospective whistleblowers used to be able to walk down the northern side of Fleet Street and go past three or four newspapers.

"If one knocked you back, you could go into the next one. Nowadays it would require a conscious decision and half a day to go down to Wapping, and when you got there they probably wouldn't let you in anyway."

During the course of his 20 years with the Sunday Times Knightley broke some of Fleet Street's biggest stories, including the exposure of the Thalidomide scandal in the late 1970s.

His proudest achievement, he said, was the Insight team's investigation into the tax evasions of the wealthy Vestey family. He described how a moment of luck sparked a two-year investigation, culminating in the exposure of the Vesteys' £88m scam and the amendment of British offshore tax law.

"The Vestey investigation walked into my life off the street," Knightley said. "The man who brought it in was an academic who was on holiday. He was walking past The Sunday Times and just thought, 'Maybe they'll be interested in all this research I've done'. That couldn't happen any more."

Knightley said handing over editorial budgets to accountants had also cut down reporters' opportunities to work on investigations, which were rarely deemed cost-effective. Australian newspapers, for example, were calculating stories' cost efficiency word by word, he said.

"The problem is not finding stories, it's funding the research," Knightley added. "I'm not pessimistic about the ability of modern journalists, and there are still editors who want to commission investigative stories, but it's accountants who run editorial budgets."

Knightley said he hoped the UK would see the launch of a body equivalent to the Centre for Public Integrity, which funds investigative work in the US by matching up reporters with philanthropic donors.

Got a story? Email our news team: Laura Oliver; Judith Townend or telephone +44 (0)1273 384290. You can also follow us on Twitter: @journalismnews / @LauraOliver / @JTownend.