Figures revealed by the broadcaster show the morning Radio 4 slot was downloaded 474,357 times in March, knocking former chart-topper Chris Moyles down to second place with 441,832 downloads.
The BBC has added an increasing number of radio shows to its podcasting and downloading project, which began in 2005 and is still in trial phase.
The success of Today's big 8.10am interview, which aims to set the daily political agenda, could be telling for the fortunes news programming might enjoy in an environment of time-shifted, on-demand media.
Other successes were BBC Radio's NewsPod, an evening news wrap-up presented by Eddie Mair, which was downloaded 147,664 times, and Radio 4's From Our Own Correspondent, with 145,850 downloads.
Free daily newsletter
- What will the next decade look like for journalism?
- BBC Shared Data Unit inspires data journalism teams across the UK to collaborate on public interest stories
- Weekly journalism news update: 'automated journalism', sustainable newsrooms and Newsrewired
- BBC calls on Ofcom to help with transition from the analogue era to the digital world
- Six tips to improve the audio quality of your podcast