How do you move print readers to digital? Are there other ways to hold on to subscribers besides a last-ditch deal?
Left to right: Flavio Moreira (OUL, Brazil) and Donika Lilova (FAZ, Germany) speaking at The Audiencers Festival on 21 June 2024
Last week (21 June 2024), The Audiencers Festival hosted a number of sessions from publishers around the world about how they are developing engaged, subscriber bases.
Journalism.co.uk rounds up some of the stand-out strategies and main takeaways.
In 2019, the French Canadian local newspaper, Le Soleil, was ready to be bought out. Then a global pandemic happened and plans were scuppered. A government loan bought them some time. Then Le Soleil, with five of its sister titles, went another route: they formed the country's biggest, local co-operative newsgroup, Les Coops de l'Info, owned by 350 of its employees.
A digital subscription strategy had to be fast-tracked from 12 or 18 months to 12-18 weeks. An off-the-shelf solution was brought in to make this possible in 2020.
Marc Grendon, publisher of Le Soleil says the average value of a digital subscriber is now $245 (Canadian dollars) over three years. To earn the same money from digital advertising, a reader needs to visit the site every day, read up to nine articles and see five full ad impressions - and he would not even do that.
The publisher closed its legacy print paper at the end of 2023, keeping a digital-only business with two premium plans: an e-paper or an ad-free experience on the site.
One idea: Print subscribers were handed a three-month "ease in" period with free digital access. Of those who took up the offer, a third moved on to digital plans.
The popular French sports newspaper has 2.5m digital readers and 190k paid digital subscribers.
It is trying lots of new ideas to make sure subscribers are enjoying their plans, from personalising content with their favourite sports and using gamification, such as monthly recaps of reader consumption, to deepen engagement.
One idea: L'Equipe is testing previews and teasers of content to come, as a way for readers to have something to look forward to. Marketing director Romain L'hote says this is why platforms like Netflix are so effective. But he is running into issues convincing journalists and editors that this is a good idea, as they fear this will give competitors an edge.
The Audiencers / Poool / Seb Higgins
Brazil's largest publisher, UOL, has more than 100m unique monthly website users. Only Facebook and Google command more attention.
It has a freemium business model. People can get breaking news and trustworthy journalism for free, but its best content sits behind the paywall. Advertising and subscriptions are the two core revenue streams, with the latter increasing steadily.
One idea: UOL has recruited 400 of the best journalists in Brazil who are experts in their field. A specific subscription, UOL Prime, offers exclusive analysis and investigations from 200 of them.
"People don't pay for commodity content," says editor-in-chief Flavio Moreira.
There are lots of reasons why someone might cancel a news subscription. French news organisation Libération has a plan for most scenarios.
It has 105k paying subscribers, 85 per cent digital and 15 per cent print. It also has 10m website visitors per month.
One idea: Identify subscribers at risk of leaving (inactivity, upcoming expiry date) and try to move them to longer plans by offering them a good deal.
People prefer to save money (€36) than time (two months) by switching to an annual plan. This saves "hundreds" of would-be cancellers a month, says head of subscription marketing Adèle Bacos.
Of the people who want to leave immediately, around half can be talked around to stay by reducing prices, she continues. Sometimes people need to update bank details, and smartphone push notifications are surprisingly effective, with a 52 per cent success rate when they reach the recipient.
German news organisation, FAZ, has reached 135k paying digital subscribers since launching its premium tier, FAZ+, six years ago.
That represents a 20 per cent year-on-year growth, which Donika Lilova, head of paid content subscription, attributes to a culture of testing.
It regularly tests price points and attractive offers to welcome subscribers. However, it takes a tougher stance on those about to leave.
One idea: FAZ attempts to save cancellations through last-ditch offers, but once people leave, they can only return at a standard price. No more big discounts. A risky strategy for a subscription business but one that makes people think twice before leaving.
If you like our news and feature articles, you can sign up to receive our free daily (Mon-Fri) email newsletter (mobile friendly).
Sign up to receive job alerts of your choice by email, or manage your subscription
Featured recruiter: click to view its vacancies
Regional news publication seeks a news editor who can build on its online growth and ensure that its printed paper is of the highest quality
Subscribe to our newsletter for latest news, tips, jobs and more
End that deadline stress today and find help in our freelance directory
Kindred Forest partners with Volker Lehmann and local families to bring Wild Beniano Cacao from the Amazon direct to the UK for first time. The Wild Chocolate bar blends rare flavours and sustainability: 20 per cent of profits go to rainforest conservation
Our next Newsrewired conference will be in May 2025, London.
Conferences and study weeks are fantastic opportunities to get the latest updates on the industry and network with your peers
Awards are a great way to have your hard work recognised by industry experts and celebrate your teams. Here is where you can apply
If you find your social feeds a tad too heavy on men's voices, follow and connect with these fantastic women experts on indie media
